Many Marketing organizations today have an influencer marketing strategy. The purpose of this strategy is to help with customer acquisition (number and/or rate) and the rate of product adoption.  A Tomoson poll of marketing professionals found that marketers rate influencer marketing as their fastest-growing online customer-acquisition channel, outpacing organic search and email marketing.  Participants in the study rated influencer marketing as one of their most cost-effective online customer-acquisition strategies. Many marketers believe they acquire better customers through influencer marketing.

Employing an Influencer Marketing Strategy

influencer KOLs effectiveness, marketingThis strategy entails establishing and tapping relationships with people who are perceived by the market and customer to have the ability or power to affect or sway other people’s thinking or actions. Influencers exist within every ecosystem – these can be members of the press/blog community, analysts, industry thought leaders, industry experts, trusted advisors, etc. The breadth, quantity, and quality of your influencers will impact the success of this strategy.

Before we jump into how to measure influencer marketing, we’d like to respond to a question we’re frequently asked: “What is the difference between influencer marketing and public relations?” The answer to this could be its own article, so to quickly explain the difference, we turned to our friend Chris Aarons (@Chris_Aarons), an expert in implementing influencer marketing strategies.

Chris says, “The simplest answer is that public relations is about communicating your messages to and with members of the press (and some PR firms include bloggers as well) to spread information or news. Whereas, influencer marketing focuses on identifying and securing credible third-parties with extensive networks, who may not necessarily be members of the press, to drive engagement and/or marketing objectives.” We’ll leave it to you to tweet with Chris on how you feel about this explanation!

Performance and Operational excellence assessment

Purchase Your Assessment

An Equation to Calculate the Value of Influence

Back to influencer strategy management… Relevant measures include:

  • Activity-based – number of influencers, types of influencers, and the degree of engagement by each influencer
  • Pipeline – deals and wins, influencer contributed lead and acquisition cost, sales cycle impact, and influencer lift

measuring effectiveness KOLs, marketingUltimately, what you want to know is whether influence or sway is impacting customer acquisition, and if so, how much and how fast.

Should influencer marketing be a viable strategy for your organization, you may want to think beyond counting and create a way to measure influence. In the social world, various organizations are creating influence metrics.  But influence occurs both on and offline, which means you need to be able to measure influence/sway beyond the “social digital world.” As with many key performance metrics, an influence metric is comprised of several measures.

So how might we construct such an influence marketing metric? Conceptually, we can posit that influence is derived from two variables, quality and impact. The equation would look like:

Influence = Quality (%) x Impact (#)

Factors that affect each of these variables include the following:

Quality Factors:

  1. What percentage of the desired influencers participated? 
  2. How prominently did they feature your company/product? Assign percentages to these or others you prefer [Top billing or stand-alone article/blog, subject line mention or tweet,  quote in general or related article, participation in LinkedIn Discussion]
  3. What is the overall sentiment/tone of the influencers’ content/conversation/discussion? Assign a percentage to each of these positive, negative, and neutral

Impact Factors:

  1. Quantity – the total number of tweets, shares, likes, comments, click-throughs, etc., generated by the influencers
  2. Penetration – how many of the targeted markets/communities were reached (for example, LinkedIn Groups, click throughs to links)

Add up your quality factors, add up your impact factors, and then multiply the two sums. Start by collecting the data and establishing your baseline. Monitor the change in your influence metric and analyze the impact of each factor on the score. Once you complete these steps, it will be necessary to evaluate the relationship between the influence score and your number and rate of customer acquisition.

Let us know what you think of this approach.

FAQ:

(written by Penn of Sintra.ai)
Q1: Why do many Marketing organizations invest in influencer marketing?
A: To improve customer acquisition (volume and/or rate) and accelerate product adoption. Research cited (Tomoson) indicates marketers view influencer marketing as a fast-growing and cost-effective online acquisition channel.
Q2: What is influencer marketing (in practical terms)?
A: A strategy built on establishing and leveraging relationships with credible third parties who can sway market thinking or actions—such as analysts, bloggers, press, industry experts, thought leaders, and trusted advisors.
Q3: What determines whether an influencer strategy will succeed?
A: The breadth, quantity, and quality of your influencers, plus the degree of engagement you earn from them. The strength of the ecosystem you build directly affects outcomes.
Q4: What is the difference between influencer marketing and public relations (PR)?
A: PR focuses on communicating messages with members of the press (often including bloggers) to spread information or news. Influencer marketing focuses on identifying and securing credible third parties with extensive networks—who may not be press—to drive engagement and marketing objectives.
Q5: What should you measure to manage influencer marketing effectively?
A: Two categories: activity-based measures (number/types of influencers and engagement by each) and pipeline measures (deals/wins, influencer-attributed leads, acquisition cost, sales cycle impact, and influencer lift).
Q6: What is the ultimate question influencer measurement should answer?
A: Whether influence (sway) is impacting customer acquisition—and if so, by how much and how fast.
Q7: How can you calculate an “influence” metric beyond simple counting?
A: Use a combined metric that accounts for both quality and impact:
\\text{Influence} = \\text{Quality (\\%)} \\times \\text{Impact (#)}
This helps measure influence both online and offline, not just social metrics.
Q8: What factors should be included in the Quality and Impact components?
A: Quality: % of desired influencers participating, prominence of coverage (e.g., top billing vs. mention), and sentiment/tone (positive/neutral/negative). Impact: quantity of actions (shares, comments, clicks, etc.) and penetration (reach into targeted markets/communities). Establish a baseline, monitor changes, then evaluate correlation with acquisition rate and volume.

Comments are closed.

Subscribe

“I love your articles and advice – I feel like everything you write is thought-provoking and actionable.” – Marcie, Marketing Director, Technology industry.

Join our community to gain insights into creating growth strategies and execution; and employing growth enablers, including accountability, alignment, analytics, and operational excellence.

marketing effectiveness

Best-In-Class organizations excel at evaluating and improving their Marketing effectiveness.

 

Download this FREE guide to find out how they do it.